PRESS PICKS: A common sense look at the current CFP poll (and why Bama is where it is)

STAFF REPORT

It’s becoming a clown show, actually, it already is one.

According to all the experts (and I mean all of them), Alabama should have fallen in the rankings this week due to two things - the lackluster performance against Vanderbilt and the fact that its three “most impressive wins - Kentucky, LSU, South Carolina - all lost over the weekend…” Therefore how can they still be third in the rankings?

Answer - the same way they got there.

Performances change every week. Some teams look good one week and not so the next. And that’s everybody.

As it turned out, no one lost in last week’s Top 10. No one really looked all that impressive (except No. 1 Georgia).

So, Texas moved to No. 5 and Notre Dame fell behind the Longhorns. Indiana was bumped up ahead of Tennessee. No big deal, right?

The two moves were a bit subtle and maybe not so necessary. But the committee found it to be the “right thing to do.”

Yet, no one is making a big deal of it…. why? Because Alabama wasn’t involved and this has become the focus of attention to everybody who covers college football.

Back to last week… only two teams in the SEC looked all that great - Auburn and Georgia. That’s it. No one was really dominant - not Tennessee, not Texas, not Oklahoma. But it’s that time of year. Players are hurt, tired, not as interested. It’s November football. It can get ugly.

Look at the other conferences and who “struggled” Indiana (again), Miami wasn’t all that impressive, UCLA. But they all won. Do they get penalized too?

Texas Tech finally had a blowout win. It took them a month for that to happen. Iowa? Really?

Fact is, despite what everyone thinks, this is not a beauty contest. It was no surprise that Kentucky and South Carolina lost. LSU was an easy pick to lose because they haven’t figured out how to hold a team out of the end zone when it counts.

But the Crimson Tide is the head poser. Why? Because it’s Bama and the SEC. No, they didn’t look great, and if that continues that will bear itself out in the poll (including the Auburn game).

The chance is they still go to Atlanta to face Georgia… some of you don’t want that. Other fans say the same. Why not? If you are in the top 4, you will have a month to recover. It’s a chance to play in the last championship game.

If the Tide beats Auburn, they are going to the playoffs and should stay in the top 4 (based on how the committee has handled previous teams in the field that lost a championship game).

Here is the Irony - everybody points at the 6-4 records in the league. Mediocre, they call it. Or is it the opposite? You can’t have it both ways. If Bama blows out Vandy, “they didn’t play anybody”… if SC blows out Arkansas - that just means the league is weak… the point has been made that if you are propping up the league based on the likes of South Carolina and Kentucky (who many figured were a sand castle on the shore) you were in trouble to begin with.

The Ole Miss loss was to be expected. It was set up by circumstances. So no surprise there. And, maybe, Oklahoma is playing better football but the Sooners are not that far removed from the blowout loss to the Gamecocks. That’s how the game is working this day and age.

Two more weeks of the behavior will continue to be the clown show from media members, not the committee which has probably done what others should have in the past. Schedules matter and for the first time, they are using them to prop up the right teams.

It’s about time.

2026 Standings (Last week) 

1. Rosie Langello 136-54 (10-5) .716

2. Graham Dunn 134-56 (10-5) .705

    Wesley Lyle  134-56 (12-3) .705

3. Michael Butler 131-59 (9-6) .689

5. Lindsey Bonner 127-63 (10-5) .668

    Doug Amos  127-63 (10-5) .668

7. Tim Gayle 126-64 (11-4) .663

8. Mike Peacock 125-65 (11-4) .658

9. Mike Tankersley 120-70 (8-7) .632

10. Rick Hendrick 118-72 (9-6) .621

11. Barry McKnight 114-76 (7-8) .600

Rosie Langello (WSFA Ch. 12 New and Sports)

136-54 (10-5) .716

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Gulf Shores

Marbury at Williamson - Marbury

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - Tennessee

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Kentucky

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Ohio St.

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Graham Dunn (River Region Sports/WTLS/Voice of Alabama State Hornets)  


134-56 (10-5) .705

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Gulf Shores

Marbury at Williamson - Williamson

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - Tennessee

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Missouri

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Ohio St.

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Wesley Lyle (River Region Sports)  

134-56 (12-3) .705

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Pike Road

Marbury at Williamson - Williamson

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - Tennessee

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Kentucky

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Ohio St.

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Michael Butler (WTLS 101.1&94.7 FM/1300 AM/Tallassee Times)  


131-59 (9-6) .689

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Gulf Shores

Marbury at Williamson - Williamson

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - LSU

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Missouri

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Ohio St.

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Lindsey Bonner (Sports Director - WAKA Ch. 8)  


127-63 (10-5) .668

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Gulf Shores

Marbury at Williamson - Williamson

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - Tennessee

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Kentucky

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Nebraska

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Doug Amos (ESPN The Ticket)  

127-63 (10-5) .668

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Pike Road

Marbury at Williamson - Marbury

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - Tennessee

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Missouri

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Ohio St

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Tim Gayle (River Region Sports/Montgomery Independent)  


126-64 (11-4) .663

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Gulf Shores

Marbury at Williamson - Williamson

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - LSU

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Missouri

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Nebraska

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Mike Peacock (River Region Sports/ASU Hornets Radio analyst)

125-65 (11-4) .658

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Gulf Shores

Marbury at Williamson - Marbury

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - Tennessee

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Missouri

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Ohio St.

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Mike Tankersley (River Region Sports/WTLS contributor)  


120-70 (8-7) .632

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Gulf Shores

Marbury at Williamson - Williamson

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Bayside Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - University

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - LSU

Georgia at South Carolina - South Carolina

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Missouri

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska -Nebraska

UCLA at Michigan - Michigan

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Rick Hendrick (WXFS 95.1 The Fox/PA Montgomery Biscuits)

118-72 (9-6) .621

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Pike Road

Marbury at Williamson - Williamson

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Bayside Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - LSU

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Missouri

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Ohio St.

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech

Barry McKnight (Voice of Troy Trojans) 


114-76 (7-8) .600

Daphne at Prattville - Prattville

Gulf Shores at Pike Road - Gulf Shores

Marbury at Williamson - Marbury

Montgomery Academy at Bayside Aca - Montgomery Academy

Maplesville at University Charter - Maplesville

Chattanooga at Alabama - Alabama

Samford at Auburn - Auburn

LSU at Tennessee - LSU

Georgia at South Carolina - Georgia

Texas A&M at Oklahoma - Oklahoma

Kentucky at Missouri - Missouri

Vanderbilt at Florida - Florida

Ohio St at Nebraska - Ohio St.

UCLA at Michigan - UCLA

Texas Tech at Baylor - Texas Tech